In defense of ‘birdie-or-bust’ disc golf …

It’s not uncommon for the MPO winner of a Pro Tour event to finish 30-plus strokes under par. And while the average FPO winner might not produce quite as jaw-dropping of a score, over the course of a three- or four-round tournament, the ladies are routinely double-digits below par, too.

You don’t see much of this from disc golf’s more handsome cousin …

Ball golf.

For some disc golf fans, this is seen as a problem, as it makes the sport appear too easy. For others, who cares how far under par the winner gets? The fewest strokes wins – that’s that.

I’m with the latter.

There’s nothing wrong with birdie-or-bust disc golf.

DGPT: Eagle McMahon

Let me tell you why …

Par is a man-made concept with its roots firmly planted in traditional golf. The game traces its origins back to 15th-century Scotland. However, it wasn’t until the late 19th century the term “par” was used as a target score for golfers. Oddly enough, the word “bogey” was employed interchangeably with par to express the exact same concept – my how times have changed.

At the turn of the 20th century, though, par became synonymous with an ideal score for gifted golfers, while bogey was used as a goal post of sorts for more recreational golfers on the course.

As time (and technology) advanced, radio broadcasts of golf tournaments began using the notion of par as a way to help listeners better visualize the holes they couldn’t see for themselves – what it’d take to score well on them, at least. Furthermore, instead of counting a totality of strokes, relative to par, scores were represented by smaller, more manageable numbers for audiences.

History lesson aside …

Do you know what’s STILL the point of ball golf, as well as disc golf?

Counting strokes.

DGPT: Nikko Locastro

In disc golf, with respect to par, score means nothing – it’s the total number of throws that counts. At the Pro Tour level, if a par-three hole commonly results in twos, that’s fine. Naturally, to not lose strokes to the majority of the field, a pro disc golfer will need to somehow follow suit.

Conversely, if the same par-three hole resulted in fours and fives, that’d be fine, as well. In reality, the ONLY time par should matter is if a player misses a hole, as – in accordance with PDGA rules – said player would automatically be awarded with a score of par-plus-four.

Ouch.

Yes, I get that par should serve as an estimate of the score a hole should produce. But if everyone plays the same course with the same par on each hole and the best of the lot goes WAY under it, go ahead – adjust par like a madman. It’ll likely change the way others perceive the course. Initially, it might even change the discs and strategies first-time golfers go with …

But you know what it won’t change?

The outcome.

It’s strokes, folks.

Have anything to add? Take to Twitter to let us know – we’ll actually (for real) get back to you.

Editor’s Suggestions:

Real quick, if you happen to buy something through a link in this article, there’s a chance we’ll get a small share of the sale. It’s how we keep the lights on. To learn more, click here.

Photo of author

Taylor Larsen

Taylor Larsen is a staff writer for Green Splatter. He uses disc golf to self-reflect, pondering questions like, "Where the heck did I throw that?" and "What happens if the disc lands on top of the basket?" He resides in Utah with his dog, Banks, who loves to chase frisbees of all sorts.

Leave a Comment